The RateMyPlacement Blog

Experience or Exploitation?

Tuesday, 21st July 2009

Given the current economic situation, an increasing number of students and graduates are working for free as the race for work experience gets tougher. 49% apparently, according to recent research by the National Council for Work Experience (NCWE), have worked unpaid for one month or more.

Experience or Exploitation?This raises the question – is an unpaid work placement or internship work experience or exploitation? According to the survey, 67% felt exploited or undervalued by working for free and it appears that there are some companies out there who are using the recession as an excuse to bring in talented students and graduates and have them work for nothing.

Whilst there are some industries, such as Media and PR, where an unpaid internship appears to be standard practice as a way into the industry, the advice from RateMyPlacement is to be careful before entering into any unpaid work. Firstly, despite what the Press would have you believe, there are still paid-opportunities out there for students and graduates looking for work experience this summer (and 10,000 graduate jobs still available too!) so students should not just resign themselves to working for nothing. Secondly, if you do decide to do an unpaid internship or placement, then it’s vital that both you and the employer go into it with the right expectations. You are not an employee of that company; you are there on a voluntary basis, with no actual legal obligation to complete the work. Obviously be sure to enquire about the actual employment opportunities after the placement or internship is over – make sure they are not just going to replace you with the next student that comes along willing to work for free.

The NCWE provide some expert tips:

  • Discuss the purpose of the internship and clarify expectations from the start
  • Ensure the placement is valuable – does it give insight into a particular industry? Will it improve certain skills or clarify career aspirations?
  • Discuss the possibilities of any future paid work with employer, pointing out the skills that you have gained during the internship.
  • Re-consider the value of the internship if it ceases to supply useful contacts and training opportunities
  • Everyone has a choice and if the balance between valuable work experience tips into exploitation then it is up to you to decide whether to continue or not

There is no doubt that an unpaid placement can give you the foot in the door and experience you need but this should be weighed against the fact that you are providing your services and skills for free. Given the rising debt of today’s students, you need to ask if you can really justify working for free and not undervalue the skills and knowledge that you can bring to an organisation.

Check out our expert Advice section for more information on applying and securing placements and internships.

by

Your Comments

  • Personally I am off the strong opinion that unpaid work experience is exploitation, albeit institutionalised in some industries. If exploitation isn’t bad enough I feel it is in many ways it elitist as only those who can live with their parents or afford not to work for periods of a couple of months can take part, this obviously puts those who need to do paid work at a disadvantage.

    Many industries like PR, Advertising, Design and Media have managed to get themselves in the position where graduates know they need work experience to enter a paid job, and are prepared to undertake any form of work experience going. With all these applications and students willing to work for free, why would the industry need to pay them? A fundamental shift needs to occur, either in the industry, or driven by the government that recognises all students need work experience, and gives a minimum wage to the student, or subsidy to the employer who takes on a work experience student. After all, the more students who leave university with relevant work experience the more they will contribute to the economy, and any short term deficits will be repaid.

    A recent report by Alan Milburn talks about the elitist nature of some internships, the full meaty 167 page document can be read here http://www.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/media/227102/fair-access.pdf. Look out for a blog from us soon about this.

    ali – 22nd Jul 2009

  • A strongly worded article in the FT today takes the opinion that unpaid work experience “demeans nearly all those who touch it. It is time to tear it down and start again.” A well written article and some good points

    http://tinyurl.com/lhzx67

    I think the problem is that there will always be a pool of students who are willing to work for free, and when there is demand companies will be happy to supply unpaid experience. It is going to take government intervention to stop it, and hopefully the Milburn report will go some way to improving the situation for all.

    ali – 28th Jul 2009

Add a Comment

  • Bloomberg LP
  • PwC
  • Reckitt Benckiser
  • Savills
  • Bloomberg LP
  • Bank of America Merrill Lynch
  • Stephenson Harwood
  • Aldi
  • Reckitt Benckiser
  • ProspectSoft Ltd
  • Enterprise Rent-A-Car
  • HSBC Bank PLC
  • L'Oreal
  • BP
  • Accenture